Podlings Over A Year Old With A Release

This is a list of all the podlings over a year old that have done a release and most other Incubator requirements. The comment underneath is why they're still here, followed by a suggestion for what to do.

Ambari Incubator 2011-08-30 623 False group-2 True True 2012-05-10 369 0,0,0 25 0 True True True True True True True True

• held for diversity, commits look active and 10 different commiters this year,
• need to investigate affiliations - see private list discussion May 21st
  

Droids HttpComponents, Lucene 2008-10-09 1678 False group-2 True True 2012-03-02 438 0,0,0 9 0 True True True True True True True True

• size and activity. Only two commiters this year but some dev going on
• graduate - they're now wondering if the name "Droids" will be a problem
  

HCatalog Incubator 2011-03-14 792 False group-3 True True 2013-01-24 110 0,1,1 12 0 True True True True True True True True

• in process of graduating to sub project of Hive
  

JSPWiki Incubator 2007-09-17 2066 False group-1 True True 2012-12-02 163 0,0,4 13 2 True True True True True True True True

• ready to go
• push them to graduate - it's happening
  

Mesos Incubator 2010-12-23 873 False group-1 True True 2013-02-09 94 0,1,1 10 0 True True True True True True True True

• held back due to size and activity but looks ok to me, they struggle to get binding votes
• should just graduate - prompted on ML they'll look at it happening June/July
  

NPanday Incubator 2010-08-13 1005 False group-2 True True 2012-03-02 438 0,0,0 10 0 True True True True True True True True

• only two commiters this year and one only one commit, and low activity
• however it looks like a credible project to me with users, the Incubator is not really adding value, so i say add mentors and graduate as probationary TLP
  

ODF Toolkit Incubator 2011-08-01 652 False group-1 True True 2012-03-02 438 0,0,0 - 1 True True True True True True True True

• 4 committers this year, some activity and they seem to know what they're doing, what value is the Incubator adding?
• graduate
  

Celix Incubator 2010-11-02 924 False group-1 True True 2013-01-08 126 0,0,1 5 1 True True True True True True False True

• size and activity. Only two commiters this year and not very active
• graduate as probationary TLP?
  

Chukwa Incubator 2010-07-14 1035 False group-1 True True 2012-12-16 149 0,0,4 16 4 True True True True True True True True

• size and activity. Four commiters this year and not very active
• graduate as probationary TLP?
  

S4 Incubator 2011-09-26 596 False group-3 True True 2013-02-06 97 0,1,2 9 0 True True True True True True True True

• only 2 committers this year, not really active, but they're doing stuff, adding commiters, making releases
• graduate as probationary TLP - started discussion on their dev list
  

Tashi Incubator 2008-09-04 1713 False group-1 True True 2012-07-06 312 0,0,0 6 1 True True True True True True True True

• only one committer this year and not very active and not much mail traffic
• if they want to keep trying and have an active mentor then ok keep incubating