Differences between revisions 29 and 30
Revision 29 as of 2014-11-12 11:16:56
Size: 4448
Editor: JakobFrank
Comment: Updated Implementation Report
Revision 30 as of 2014-11-12 11:23:48
Size: 4630
Editor: JakobFrank
Comment: added link to the W3C conformance report
Deletions are marked like this. Additions are marked like this.
Line 43: Line 43:
The compliance report for this version is available in the [[https://dvcs.w3.org/hg/ldpwg/raw-file/2bba1e7bd799/tests/reports/ldp.html#subj_8|Implementation Conformance Report]].

Marmotta LDP Implementation Report

Relevant Documents


Implementation Report Revisions

Test Suite

Implementation Restrictions

We agree on some restrictions:

  • Identifiers

    • trailing slash is ignored (removed) for URI generation.
    • query part of an URL will never be used as part of a URI.
      • query parameters might be used for some LDP operations such as non-membership triples (tbd)
    • resources with fragments can't be addressed directly, but can be accessed via their container (URL without fragment)
  • Storage

    • internally every LDPR will be stored in its own (Sesame) context (as could be interpreted from sec

    • that would allow us to extend the Resource concept beyond the common understanding in triplestores (just one level of outgoing triples)
  • Paging and Sorting is not supported

    • Anyway the WG has resolved (Feb 17, 2014) to move out paging and ordering into a separate spec: 2014-02-17#r5

  • ETags for LDP-RS are weak and soley based on the dcterms:modified value, while ETags for LDP-NR are based on the md5sum of the file content.

  • Both LDP-NR and LDP-NR are supported

    • Our interpretation of Sec. implements that POST of content types not managed by the platform (i.e., not suitable Rio parser registered) adds a LDP-RS as member of the container, linking (dct:hasFormat/dct:isFormatOf) to the actual LDP-NR (URI is build by appending the file extension according the content type)

  • Only LDP-BC is supported, since current use cases do not justify the inclusion of LDP-DC or LDP-IC

  • Sec. (rel='ldp:constrainedBy'-Link) is fulfilled by pointing to this page.

    • Link: <http://wiki.apache.org/marmotta/LDPImplementationReport/2014-09-16>; rel="http://www.w3.org/ns/ldp#constrainedBy"

  • PATCH accepts application/rdf-patch only (LD Patch support will be discussed)

    • Patches with the predicate ldp:contains will result in a HTTP 409 Conflict

The compliance report for this version is available in the Implementation Conformance Report.


For accessing this experimental feature you'd need to follow these instructions:

First install all artifacts:

mvn install

And launch the webapp (at launchers/marmotta-webapp/ ) with the experimental features enabled:

mvn clean tomcat7:run -Pexperimental,kiwi,cleanall


Although not strictly required, it would be good to have some background what's happening under the hood with these commands. For that, please refer to the relevant documents listed above.

Add a source resource to a container

curl -i -X POST -d @src/test/resources/test.ttl -H "Content-Type: text/turtle" -H "Slug: test" http://localhost:8080/ldp/container1
curl -i -H "Accept: text/turtle" http://localhost:8080/ldp/container1/test

Add a binary resource to a container

curl -i -X POST --data-binary @src/test/resources/test.png -H "Content-Type: image/png" -H "Slug: test2" http://localhost:8080/ldp/container2
curl -i http://localhost:8080/ldp/container2/test2
curl -i -H "Accept: text/turtle" http://localhost:8080/ldp/container2/test2.png
curl -i -H "Accept:  image/png" http://localhost:8080/ldp/container2/test2.png

LDPImplementationReport (last edited 2014-11-12 11:23:48 by JakobFrank)