How To Mitigate Login Attacks

Brute force and dictionary attacks use recursive attempts to guess passwords. One of the most effective approaches to mitigate this is to implement a delay between login attempts, which effectively slows down these scripts just enough to render them useless. The problem with implementing 'account lockout' as an alternative is that its open for abuse, and also may create some administrative overhead. This short article uses a simplified example to illustrate this principle.

1. The first step is to create a simple Pojo that represents a failed login, we give it the ability to count failed attempts, and give it a time to live.

 * @author Peter Stavrinides
public class FailedLogin {

        /** Tracks the number of failed login attempts */
        private int failedLoginCount_ = 0;

        /** The number of times sleep was incurred */
        private int sleepCount = 0;
        /** The delay period (10 minutes) */
        private int SLEEP_INTERVAL = 600000; 
        /** The login expired time */
        private Date expireTime_ = null;
        /** 2 Hours of inactivity expires the counter */
        private final int TIME_TO_LIVE = 2;
         * A method to increment the failed logins
         * @throws InterruptedException 
        public void incrementFailedLoginCount() throws InterruptedException {
                //reset all counters if the object expired
                if (isExpired()) {
                        sleepCount = 0;
                        failedLoginCount_ = 0;
                 //increment the failed login counter
                failedLoginCount_ += 1;

                //every 5th failed login we double the sleep period 
                if(failedLoginCount_ == 5){
                        sleepCount +=1; failedLoginCount_ = 0;
                        SLEEP_INTERVAL = (SLEEP_INTERVAL * 2);
                //set the expires time
                Calendar ts = Calendar.getInstance();
                ts.add(Calendar.HOUR, 2);
                expireTime_ = new Date(ts.getTimeInMillis());

        /** @return true if this object is expired */
        public boolean isExpired() {
                if(expireTime_ == null){
                        return false;
                Date now = new Date();
                long diff = now.getTime() - expireTime_.getTime();
                int hours = (int) (Math.floor(diff / 1000 / 60 / 60));
                // the object has expired 
                if (hours >= TIME_TO_LIVE) {
                        return true;
                return false;
         * @throws InterruptedException
        public FailedLogin() throws InterruptedException{

2. The next step is to create a Tapestry Singleton service. The service uses a map to store failed login attempts, and uses the callers IP address as an identifier.

public class FailedLoginTracker {
        /** A map to store the FailedLogin objects */
        private static ConcurrentHashMap<String, FailedLogin> failedLogins_ = new ConcurrentHashMap<String, FailedLogin>();
         * @param ipAddress
         * @throws InterruptedException
        public void setFailedLogin(String ipAddress) throws InterruptedException{
                FailedLogin login = null;
                        login  = failedLogins_.get(ipAddress);
                        //construction ensures increment by 1
                        login = new FailedLogin();
                failedLogins_.put(ipAddress, login);
                // Not essential, but I prefer to take out the trash

         * A method to clean the map of failed logins
         * that have passed their time to live
        private void cleanUpExpired() {
                for(String ip : failedLogins_.keySet()) {

3. Lastly we add a simple binding in AppModule... a Singleton is the default scope so we only require the following:



I have tried to keep the example above concise, but there are a several enhancements that come to mind:

By combining these checks intelligently you can get a good indication of a scripted attack.

... any suggestions, corrections etc. are encouraged!


Suggestion: After 3 failed login attempts, show a CAPTCHA image.

Tapestry5HowToMitigateLoginAttacks (last edited 2009-09-20 23:20:32 by localhost)